Ibn 'Ata' ibn Rabah ibn Yasar ibn al-'Abbas ibn Muhammad ibn al-Hasan ibn 'Ali ibn Abi Talib.
Ibn al-Qattan also cited him, and most of the historians who mentioned the lineage of Ibn Tumart followed him, with the addition of Sufyan, whom Ibn al-Qattan omitted in this narration after 'Adnan.
The third: It agrees with the first up to Rabah, then it ends with Muhammad ibn Sulwan ibn 'Abd Allah ibn al-Hasan ibn al-Hasan ibn 'Ali ibn Abi Talib. Ibn Khaldun cited him, and he was followed in this by al-Marrakshi, who relied on this path, as al-Zurqashi narrated from Ibn Nakhil: "And there is no path among them that ends with al-Hasan ibn al-Hasan except this path."
The fourth: Muhammad ibn 'Abd Allah ibn Wajlid ibn Yamusil ibn Hamzah ibn 'Isa ibn Idris ibn Idris ibn 'Abd Allah ibn al-Hasan ibn 'Ali ibn Abi Talib. Ibn al-Qattan cited him, and Abu al-Qasim al-Misri, who states that this path is transmitted from those whose transmission is trusted among his relatives and others. Whereas the first path is not known to his relatives and those concerned with this matter. Ibn Khaldun mentioned part of this path, transmitting from Ibn Rushayq.
If we go beyond this difference in the prophetic lineage paths of Ibn Tumart to the origin of this lineage itself, we find the historians divided regarding it, between those who deny it and those who affirm it, either explicitly or implicitly.
Ibn al-Qattan, *Nazm al-Juman*. With the addition of Yahya after Jabir. *Al-Muqtabas min al-Ansab fi Ma'rifat al-Ashab*. See: Abu al-Qasim al-Misri. Ibn Khallikan, *Wafayat*. Ibn Khaldun, *Al-'Ibar*. With the omission of Sufyan. Ibn al-Khatib, no. 465. *Al-Mu'nis*. Ibn Abi al-Dinar, no. 117. *Mafakhir al-Barbar*, an anonymous author, no. 75. *Al-Hullal al-Mawshiyah*. *Al-Hullal*, no. 56. Al-Zurqashi, *Tarikh al-Dawlatayn*. Al-Marrakshi, *Al-Mu'jib*. Ibn al-Qattan, *Nazm al-Juman*. Abu al-Qasim al-Misri, *Al-Muqtabas min al-Ansab fi Ma'rifat al-Ashab*. With the addition of 'Ubayd Allah after 'Isa. Ibn Khaldun, *Al-'Ibar*. He cited another incomplete path that includes Berber names.