Sudan Archive

Open the original scan

OriginalTranslateMachine translation — not a source document

Between the two elements of the dialogue, the apparent weakness of the Almohad party and its eventual demise with the disappearance of Almohad rule. Thus, the jurisprudential approach based on branches and imitation prevailed.

Often, scholars and students have misinterpreted this outcome as the victory of the Maliki school over the Murabit school, and its complete return to dominance over the Maghreb as it was before. The truth is that it was the victory of the method of branches and imitation over the method of principles and ijtihad. As the Almohad school was not hostile to the Maliki school, as has been explained.

Muhammad al-Muqri, as narrated by Ahmad Baba, depicted this fate that jurisprudence reached in later eras, revealing the methodological corruption that had become rampant in Maliki jurisprudence in the Maghreb, and indicating that the conflict was between the method of branches and the method of principles. As for those before them, they preserved abridgments, and then wrote extensive commentaries and major works on principles. They contented themselves with memorizing what was brief in wording and limited in scope. They spent their lives unraveling its puzzles and understanding its symbols, and they did not reach the point of correcting what was in it by referring it back to its principles. Rather, it was a locked solution, and an understanding of a generalized matter, and the study of notes that they claimed would rouse the souls. So, while we find ourselves turning away from the books of the imams to the books of the sheikhs, we are presented with notes from the ignorant, and even drafts of the abrogated.

It is clear from the foregoing that the reformist experiment initiated by Ibn Tumart in the field of principles and jurisprudence did not have a deep enough impact to withstand the opposing factors. Its effect in the Maghreb was limited in scope and limited in time.

If we wish to seek the reasons that led to this outcome, we find a group of reasons, among which we mention the following: First: The deep-rootedness of the jurisprudential method in the Maghreb, its firm establishment there, and the people's adherence to it. (See: Al-Fard fi al-Firaq al-Islamiyyah fi al-Shamal, p. 135, 362. The eighth century, as al-Muqri most likely died in 965 AH / 1557 AD). (Al-Ifriqi: Al-Timbukti - Nayl al-Ibtihaj, p. 276-277).

Text produced by OCR — report an error