Sudan Archive

Open the original scan

OriginalTranslateMachine translation — not a source document

Regarding his discussion of learning this science, he says: Abu al-Abbas ibn Khalid, and some students passing through Bijaya, completed his reading in two ways: the way of the ancients, Abu Nasr al-Farabi and others, and the way of the later scholars, Ibn al-Din and others, and the way of the middle scholars, such as Ibn Sina and others. And this wide spread of logic found its way into mixing with all other sciences, so these sciences, such as theology, grammar, jurisprudence, and its principles, began to follow it in their methodology of classification and reasoning for their issues. And gradually the tendency to oppose it disappeared, and it became one of the sciences that every student takes, just as they take jurisprudence, grammar, and others, and it merged into other sciences, and other sciences merged into it, as we see with Ibn Arafa al-Warghami (d. 1400 AH / 1977 AD) in his book *Al-Hudud* and in his jurisprudential epitome. And the primary reason for the Maghreb people's shift from rejecting logic to accepting the rational methodology advocated by Ibn Tumart.

Debate and Disputation: Debate and disputation were not prevalent in the Maghreb before the call of the Mahdi, because these two forms of intellectual activity arise from the divergence of doctrines, which was not available except in Andalusia. So a form of debate arose there, with Ibn Hazm al-Zahiri as its primary focus, in what he confronted the Jews and Christians with regarding creed, and what he confronted the Malikis with regarding jurisprudence. When Ibn Tumart came, and he had mastered the methods of debate and disputation in the East, he inaugurated a new era in the Maghreb, through what he practiced practically, as we saw in his famous debate with the jurists of Aghmat. And through what he introduced of a new perspective in creed and jurisprudence that differed from the established norms. This created a suitable atmosphere for the emergence of debate and disputation, due to the new clash of viewpoints that necessitated each of the opposing parties to defend their viewpoint and support it with arguments and proofs.

See: Abd al-Majid al-Najjar, *The Connection of Logic with Maliki Jurisprudence as concluded by Ibn Arafa al-Warghami* (p. 256 onwards), published in: *The First Symposium of Ibn Arafa*, published by the Ministry of Culture, Tunis (1977). See what was mentioned earlier (p. 257 onwards).

Text produced by OCR — report an error